The show is centered around a bunch of high school students who are playing "The Game," which was obviously related to love and dating. The actual rules and objectives of the game were the least clear, but from what Amy and I deduced there was no way to win. Only ways to lose. You were out of the game (and "bled" rose petals all over the place) if you got your heart broken. The metaphor mostly seems simple enough, but it took me and Amy a really long time to get to that conclusion. Though you got the general gist of whether the scene was good or bad, the logistics were difficult to decipher.
However, the energy of the cast made up for the kinks that still need to be worked out. The show was young (I'd say "hip" but that automatically makes me not so), relevant, and pretty daring at times. The opening number was spectacular, reminiscent of "Totally Fucked" if I do say so myself. But all the little details, usually involving cell phone usage, were just so accurate in how acutely awkward they were; the phone-tag scene comes to mind immediately. Also, the amount of "real" dancing in the show was impressive. The girls especially were very talented and they incorporated some pretty hard-core contemporary steps, which you usually don't see in any musical.
The second act needed a lot more work than the first. It becamse very dialogue heavy and, in my opinion, had one too many subplots. Jason became a caricature and at times seemed like he was just imitating Heath Ledger's Joker. And it was a poor imitation at that. The excessive gunfire at the end was also irritating. As were some of the incredibly long dances (the number about the pills and sex come to mind). Also, "To Write Love On Her Arms" made me cringe.
Which leads me to my final criticism: I know that cutting is a difficult, sensitive and VERY important topic, and I respected the show for addressing it (because I think it often gets left by the wayside when suicide gets brought up) but that number added nothing to the discussion or the show. Come to think of it now, the show almost threw that issue away, making it leverage for blackmail and, in the end, curing it with the love from a significant other. Also, the severity of the condition was damped by the fact that people were metaphorically cutting themselves and each other throughout the whole show. I get that it was part of that larger metaphor, beating yourself up and breaking your own heart, etc. but...I don't know. Clearly this is an issue very close to me; I was proud I made it through the big song and actually watched the character cut, but at the end I was so shaky and light-headed I had to go lay down in the lobby for a few minutes. OK, sorry this has turned into more of a rant. That was not my intention. Let's get back on track:
I really, really enjoyed this show. There are definitely things to be tweaked or, in very few cases, reworked, but the show took a lot of risks and had a lot of fun. It was loud, it was funny, it was relevant. Definitely 2nd favorite of the summer.